A jury found 3.3 million false claims at CVS's Omnicare. The $948.8 million judgment is settling for $440 million.

By ··1 min read·2 sources

Omnicare filed for bankruptcy two months after the judgment. The government now stands to collect less than half, and CVS admits nothing.

A federal jury found in April 2025 that Omnicare billed Medicare, Medicaid and TRICARE for long-term-care prescriptions without valid orders between 2010 and 2018. In July 2025 the judge imposed about $948.8 million, including trebled damages and $542 million in penalties, and held CVS jointly liable for $164.8 million.

Omnicare appealed, then entered Chapter 11 in September 2025. In July 2026 CVS, Omnicare and the Justice Department reached a deal: the government gets at least $440 million, with $130 million from CVS up front and $310 million due by March 2028. CVS says the agreement is not an admission of wrongdoing.

A second agreement matters as much. It releases CVS from potential fraudulent-transfer claims over a $660 million distribution Omnicare paid to CVS entities in 2023.

Put together: a subsidiary paid its parent $660 million, lost at trial, went bankrupt, and the judgment was cut by more than half. A jury verdict is the strongest outcome the False Claims Act can produce, and this one still ended in a discount.

Sources

  1. fiercehealthcare.com · fiercehealthcare.com/payers/cvs-omnicare-unit-agrees-440m-settlement-doj-ongoing-fraud-cas…
  2. beckershospitalreview.com · beckershospitalreview.com/legal-regulatory-issues/cvs-omnicare-reach-440m-justice-departme…

Cite this report

The Precedent. "A jury found 3.3 million false claims at CVS's Omnicare. The $948.8 million judgment is settling for $440 million.." October 6, 2026. https://theprecedent.org/article/a-jury-found-33-million-false-claims-at-cvss-omnicare-the-9488-million-judgment

Companies in this report