Methodology & contact

Q&A

How The Precedent works, how scores are calculated, and how to submit tips or get in contact.

Q1

What is The Precedent and who is it for?

The Precedent is an independent regulatory intelligence publication tracking governance failures and controversy across the US pharmaceutical industry. It is designed for policy researchers, journalists, investors, and the public who want an unvarnished record of corporate conduct.

Q2

How is the RedFlag score calculated?

The RedFlag score is a composite 0–100 index derived from four weighted factors: volume of documented regulatory actions (40%), severity of underlying conduct (30%), quality of institutional response (20%), and repeat enforcement exposure (10%). All source data is drawn from DOJ, FDA, CMS, FTC, and SEC public records. Scores are provisional estimates; shared proceedings may appear against multiple companies.

Q3

What counts as a 'controversy' in the index?

A controversy is any documented instance of regulatory enforcement, federal or state investigation, litigation resulting in settlement or judgment, or credible whistleblower disclosure. We do not include matters that remain entirely at the allegation stage without corroborating regulatory action.

Q4

How often is the RedFlag Index™ updated?

The index is updated on the first of each month. Scores reflect the prior calendar month's regulatory record. Breaking developments — new indictments or emergency enforcement — are flagged in real time via RegulationWatch.

Q5

Can companies respond to their scores?

Yes. Companies are notified of their preliminary score before publication and invited to submit a formal response. Verified factual corrections are incorporated. Substantive responses are published alongside the company's entry.

Q6

How do I submit a tip or report a new controversy?

Tips can be submitted via our secure contact channel. We accept documentation, court records, internal communications, and direct whistleblower accounts. All sources are protected and handled in accordance with standard journalistic practice.