Fruth reimbursement claims move to arbitration and Missouri federal court
A West Virginia federal judge ordered arbitration of Fruth's claims against OptumRx and Caremark. Claims against Express Scripts were severed and transferred to Missouri.
Judge Thomas E. Johnston ruled on September 28, 2026, in Fruth, Inc. v. OptumRx, Inc., et al., No. 2:25-cv-00751, Southern District of West Virginia. The order compelled arbitration for OptumRx and Caremark and transferred the Express Scripts claims to the Eastern District of Missouri.
Fruth alleged violations of West Virginia's Pharmacy Audit Integrity Act, including provisions concerning a $10.49 dispensing fee and reimbursement relative to PBM-owned pharmacies. Its claims invoke W. Va. Code §§ 33-51-9(e) and (f).
The court granted the companies' arbitration and transfer motions and stayed the remaining case pending arbitration.
The transferred Express Scripts proceeding appears as No. 4:26-cv-01548 in Missouri, where the West Virginia order is docketed as document 106. The ruling awards no damages and establishes no admission of liability. No subsequent appellate disposition was verified.
Cite this report
The Precedent. "Fruth reimbursement claims move to arbitration and Missouri federal court." September 29, 2026. https://theprecedent.org/article/fruth-reimbursement-claims-move-to-arbitration-and-missouri-federal-court
