House Oversight chair investigates whether PBMs used audits to punish pharmacies that backed reform
Chairman James Comer asked CVS Caremark, Express Scripts and Optum Rx for documents and briefings after independent pharmacies that supported H.R. 6610 reported a surge of burdensome audits. The companies have not been accused in any proceeding.
House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform Chairman James Comer (R-Ky.) sent letters on October 23, 2026, to CVS Caremark, Express Scripts and Optum Rx, opening an investigation into whether the pharmacy benefit managers targeted independent pharmacies with punitive audits in retaliation for supporting reform legislation.
The legislation is H.R. 6610, the Pharmacists Fight Back in FEHB Plans Act, which the committee marked up in July. According to the committee, after the markup several independent pharmacies that had backed its work received an unusual number of burdensome audit notices in quick succession from several PBMs. One audit concerned a medication costing $0.99 and, the committee said, consumed hundreds of hours of pharmacy staff time.
Comer requested documents and communications, staff-level briefings, information on audit practices and how pharmacies are selected, nationwide audit totals broken down by state and by affiliated and non-affiliated pharmacies, and detailed audit records for independent pharmacies in Kentucky, Mississippi and Florida. Briefings were requested by October 30 and documents by November 6.
A CVS spokesperson said the company had received the letter and planned to respond. Optum Rx declined to comment. The letters raise questions; they are not findings, and no PBM has been charged with retaliation.
The inquiry adds to the committee's long-running PBM investigation, including its July 2024 report concluding that the three largest PBMs used anticompetitive tactics to dominate the market. It also lands as Congress and CMS implement PBM provisions enacted in the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2026.
Sources
- oversight.house.gov · oversight.house.gov/release/comer-investigates-pbms-for-retaliatory-audits-of-independent-…
- oversight.house.gov · oversight.house.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Express-Scripts-Audit-Letter_10.23.26.pdf
- fiercehealthcare.com · fiercehealthcare.com/payers/house-oversight-committee-chair-probes-pbms-independent-pharma…
- drugtopics.com · drugtopics.com/view/pbm-audit-practices-under-scrutiny-what-the-house-inquiry-means-for-in…
- beckerspayer.com · beckerspayer.com/?p=29939
Cite this report
The Precedent. "House Oversight chair investigates whether PBMs used audits to punish pharmacies that backed reform." October 26, 2026. https://theprecedent.org/article/house-oversight-chair-investigates-whether-pbms-used-audits-to-punish-pharmacies
