Kentucky's opioid case against two PBMs is going to federal court. Its allegations are still unanswered.
A Sixth Circuit ruling settles where the case is heard. Two years after Kentucky sued, no court has tested what Express Scripts and Optum actually did.
Kentucky's attorney general sued Express Scripts in September 2024 and added Optum two months later. The state alleges the companies colluded with opioid makers on deceptive marketing, restricted tools that would have limited prescribing, and dispensed opioids by mail order without effective controls. Both deny it.
The fight since has been about venue. The PBMs moved the case to federal court, arguing they act under federal officers when they serve federal health plans. A district judge sent it back to state court. On September 18, 2026, the Sixth Circuit reversed. That ruling picks a courtroom and decides nothing about the merits.
This is how PBM accountability tends to go: procedure first, substance later or never. The FTC's insulin case is ending in consent orders with no fines and no admissions. In Arkansas, twelve independent pharmacies had to file their own lawsuit in September, alleging Express Scripts paid below the state's legal floor on roughly 48,300 prescriptions. A House Judiciary staff report in January concluded CVS may have broken antitrust law by using audits and cease-and-desist letters against independent pharmacies. No charge has followed.
Sources
- kentuckylantern.com · kentuckylantern.com/briefs/kentucky-attorney-general-sues-express-scripts-alleging-company…
- healthcaredive.com · healthcaredive.com/news/express-scripts-arkansas-pharmacy-lawsuit-underpayment-nadac/83045…
- judiciary.house.gov · judiciary.house.gov/media/press-releases/new-report-reveals-cvs-health-targeted-competitor…
Cite this report
The Precedent. "Kentucky's opioid case against two PBMs is going to federal court. Its allegations are still unanswered.." September 8, 2026. https://theprecedent.org/article/kentuckys-opioid-case-against-two-pbms-is-going-to-federal-court-its-allegations
